In an age where data drives almost every sector, the healthcare industry is no exception. The digital transformation has revolutionised medicine, but amidst this evolution the ownership of patient data has emerged as a critical issue. Who truly owns health data—the patients to whom it pertains, or the entities that collect and manage it? This complex question strikes at the heart of modern healthcare.
The healthcare data economy is booming, driven by a desire to solve intricate health issues, forecast forthcoming challenges, reduce public costs, and boost returns. Predictions suggest that the health data sector's value would soar to $34.27 billion by 2022, growing at an astounding annual rate of 22%. Yet, the central question lingers—who fundamentally owns this data?
Calls for patient ownership of health data are increasingly prominent. These demands stem from two primary concerns: the way organisations manage and utilise health data, and the monetization of this data as a valuable digital asset. The subsequent sections explore these issues in-depth, considering the implications, legalities, and potential paths toward resolving them.
Instances of data misuse in the healthcare sector are not uncommon. For instance, the Royal Free Hospital in London gave access to 1.6 million health records to Google's AI subsidiary, DeepMind, to develop an app that analyses results for patients at risk of acute kidney injury. Similarly, IT platform flaws jeopardised the data of 26 million GPs.
In the US, a class-action lawsuit against the University of Chicago and Google alleged that the medical centre shared hundreds of thousands of patient records with Google without adequately anonymizing the data. These instances underscore the urgency of redefining ownership and control of health data.
Globally, the legal framework surrounding health data ownership varies. GDPR, for instance, frames regulations around "personal data" and "data subjects" but does not explicitly confer ownership of data. Similarly, the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services defines data ownership from a researcher's perspective, emphasising possession and responsibility over mere ownership.
"Medicine is a science of uncertainty and an art of probability." - William Osler
UK laws reflect a cautious stance on declaring health data as property, generally viewing organisations, rather than patients, as owners of health records. In contrast, Belgian and Dutch laws grant individuals the right to access any personal data related to them, although true ownership remains an unresolved legal matter.
Under the current system, healthcare entities often prioritise commercial interests over patient welfare, leading to potential ethical breaches and unjust discrimination. Providing patients control over their data could mitigate such issues, fostering trust and ensuring that data usage aligns with their best interests.
Empowering patients with data ownership can result in numerous benefits:
Emerging technologies like blockchain offer innovative solutions to the issue of health data ownership. Blockchain can ensure secure, immutable records, providing patients with transparent control over their data. Projects like Linnia and Solid are already laying the groundwork for such decentralised data ownership models.
Transitioning to a patient-centric data ownership model necessitates a multi-faceted approach:
"The aim of medicine is to prevent disease and prolong life; the ideal of medicine is to eliminate the need of a physician." - William J. Mayo
In conclusion, reimagining health data ownership as a patient-centric paradigm is no longer merely an ethical imperative; it is a practical necessity. As technology continues to evolve, ensuring that patients have control over their health data can drive better healthcare outcomes, foster trust, and harness the full potential of modern medical innovations. Transitioning to this model requires collaborative efforts from policymakers, healthcare providers, technology developers, and patients themselves. Only through concerted action can the vision of patient data ownership become a reality, ultimately transforming healthcare for the better.
.png)
